Paper vs Physical Gold and Silver: What You Own and What It Costs

Paper vs. Physical Precious Metals

“Paper” gold and silver are claims on metal or on its price: shares of a bullion trust, futures contracts, unallocated metal accounts and mining shares. “Physical” means coins and bars held by you or in a vault in your name. Both follow the same metal price; they differ in what you pay, whom you depend on, and whether you can take the metal. The largest gold fund, SPDR Gold Shares, charges 0.40% a year, and only large Authorized Participants can swap its shares for gold (SPDR Gold Trust). A coin buyer pays once instead, through the premium over spot.

Neither form escapes the metal’s swings. In Bullion Trading LLC research on the 10 declines of 15% or more in the S&P 500 since 1987, gold was higher at the stock market’s low in 7 and silver in 2. A coin in a safe and a share of a fund fell together in the others.

Key findingResult
What “paper” metal isFund shares, futures, unallocated accounts and mining shares: claims on metal or on its price
Yearly fund feesSPDR Gold Shares 0.40%; iShares Gold Trust 0.25%; iShares Silver Trust 0.50%
Who can swap fund shares for metalAuthorized Participants, in blocks of 100,000 shares (SPDR Gold Trust)
Unallocated accountThe holder is an unsecured creditor of the bullion dealer
Cost of coins and barsA one-time premium over spot: a few percent for 1 oz gold, far more for silver
Federal tax on long-term gainsBullion and bullion-trust shares: collectibles, up to 28%; regulated futures: 60% long-term, 40% short-term
S&P 500 declines of 15% or more since 198710; gold higher at the low in 7 (median +5.2%); silver higher in 2 of 10
Sources: SPDR Gold Trust FAQ (January 2026); iShares; IRS Topic 409 and Form 6781; Bullion Trading LLC research using S&P 500 daily closes and LBMA prices, and Bullion Trading LLC price records.

What is paper silver (and paper gold)?

“Paper silver” is an informal name for any claim on silver that is not metal in your hands or in a vault in your name. The same goes for gold. The forms differ in what you own and in whether the metal can ever reach you.

FormWhat you ownCan you take the metal?Main risk
Bullion fund (GLD, IAU, SLV)Shares of a trust that holds barsNot directly: only Authorized Participants redeemFees; custodians
FuturesA contract for 100 oz of gold or 5,000 oz of silver on COMEXThrough the exchange, in whole contractsLeverage and margin calls
Unallocated accountA claim on the provider for ouncesOn request, if the provider can deliverThe provider’s insolvency
Mining sharesPart of a companyNoCosts, management, country
Coins and barsThe metalYou already have itPremium, storage, theft
Contract sizes: CME Group.

A bullion fund is the closest paper form to metal. The SPDR Gold Trust’s gold sits in HSBC’s vault in London and JPMorgan’s vaults in London, New York and Zurich, and the trust sells small amounts of it to pay its expenses, so each share holds slightly less gold every year. An individual who wants bars for shares has to arrange it through a broker.

Do paper and physical prices move together?

Over months and years, yes. A bullion fund’s shares track the metal minus its fee, and a futures price meets the spot price at expiry. Coins and bars sell for spot plus a retail premium, and that premium moves on its own. In the first half of 2025, with silver around $33, the typical government coin carried about 19% over the Ask. As silver more than doubled through 2025, that share fell, to 8.6% on 24 December 2025, the lowest in our records; at silver's record on 29 January 2026 it was about 10%. On 18 November 2026, with silver closing at $45.05, the typical coin carried 20.0%. The Ask is the price level dealers quote for buying.

Premium over the Ask of 1 oz silver coins, rounds and bars, in percent, Oct 2024 to Nov 2026Ten-day rolling medians of the daily premium over the Ask, Bullion Trading LLC price records. The typical government coin went from about 19% in early 2025 to a low of 8.6% on 24 December 2025, was near 10% at silver's record on 29 January 2026, and was 20.0% on 18 November 2026; its median over the whole period is 14.6%. Rounds were 18.1% and plain bars 25.0% on the last day.Government coinsNew roundsPlain 1 oz bars0%10%20%30%40%Jan 2025Jul 2025Jan 2026Jul 2026Dec 2025: 8.6%18 Nov 2026: 20.0%Silver record $118.4510-day rolling medians. Dashed: the typical coin's median since Oct 2024 (14.6%).Premium over the Ask of 1 oz silver coins, rounds and bars, in percent, Oct 2024 to Nov 2026Ten-day rolling medians of the daily premium over the Ask, Bullion Trading LLC price records. The typical government coin went from about 19% in early 2025 to a low of 8.6% on 24 December 2025, was near 10% at silver's record on 29 January 2026, and was 20.0% on 18 November 2026; its median over the whole period is 14.6%. Rounds were 18.1% and plain bars 25.0% on the last day.Government coinsRoundsBars0%10%20%30%40%2025Jul2026Jul8.6%Now: 20.0%Dashed: coins' median 14.6%.
What a physical buyer pays on top of the metal: premium over the Ask of 1 oz silver coins, rounds and bars (10-day rolling medians), beside the silver price. Source: Bullion Trading LLC price records.

Most of a premium is a fixed amount of dollars per coin, so in percent it shrinks when the price rises and widens when it falls. In a buying rush the two markets can also part for a while, as covered in the 2026 paper and physical silver gap.

What does each cost to hold?

A fund charges every year; coins and bars charge once when you buy and again through the dealer’s spread when you sell. In Bullion Trading LLC’s price records a 1 oz gold coin or bar has cost a few percent over the value of its gold. Silver also costs more over its metal: a median 14.8% for 1 oz silver coins against 2.6% for 1 oz gold coins, and 9.7% even for 100 oz silver bars.

CostBullion fundCoins and bars
To buyBrokerage commission, often zero, and the bid-ask spreadA premium over spot
To hold0.25% to 0.50% a year, paid in the trust’s metalA safe and insurance, or about 0.49% a year in a depository
To sellThe bid-ask spreadThe dealer’s buy-back spread
Ten years of feesAbout 3.9% of the holding at 0.40% a yearNone at home; about 4.8% at 0.49% a year
Fees: SPDR Gold Shares, iShares Gold Trust and iShares Silver Trust; depository rate: Texas Bullion Depository, segregated, under $500,000. Ten-year figures compound the yearly fee and ignore price changes.

The difference is a matter of years. At 0.40% a year, a fund’s fee takes as much as a 3% premium in about seven and a half years; at 0.50%, it takes roughly 30 years to match a 15% premium on silver coins, before the spreads paid on selling either way. Storage changes the sum: metal kept in a depository pays a yearly fee too.

Does gold go up during a recession?

Not reliably, and physical gold has no separate price that rises when paper gold falls. Bullion Trading LLC measured every S&P 500 decline of 15% or more since 1987, from the index’s closing high to its closing low: gold ended higher in 7 and silver in 2.

Gold and silver during S&P 500 declines of 15% or more, 1987 to 2025Grouped bar chart of the S&P 500, gold and silver from each S&P 500 peak to its trough, for the 10 declines of 15% or more since 1987. 1987: S&P 500 -33.5%, gold +6.2%, silver -11.8%; 1990: S&P 500 -19.9%, gold +6.8%, silver -10.8%; 1998: S&P 500 -19.3%, gold -6.9%, silver -9.5%; 2000–02: S&P 500 -49.1%, gold +12.1%, silver -14.3%; 2007–09: S&P 500 -56.8%, gold +25.5%, silver +1.1%; 2011: S&P 500 -19.4%, gold +7.8%, silver -36.2%; 2018: S&P 500 -19.8%, gold +4.1%, silver +3.1%; 2020: S&P 500 -33.9%, gold -4.9%, silver -31.8%; 2022: S&P 500 -25.4%, gold -7.5%, silver -16.9%; 2025: S&P 500 -18.9%, gold +2.7%, silver -7.9%. Gold was higher at the trough in 7 of 10.S&P 500GoldSilver-60%-45%-30%-15%0%+15%+30%+6%1987+7%1990-7%1998+12%2000–02+26%2007–09+8%2011+4%2018-5%2020-8%2022+3%2025Gold and silver during S&P 500 declines of 15% or more, 1987 to 2025Grouped bar chart of the S&P 500, gold and silver from each S&P 500 peak to its trough, for the 10 declines of 15% or more since 1987. 1987: S&P 500 -33.5%, gold +6.2%, silver -11.8%; 1990: S&P 500 -19.9%, gold +6.8%, silver -10.8%; 1998: S&P 500 -19.3%, gold -6.9%, silver -9.5%; 2000–02: S&P 500 -49.1%, gold +12.1%, silver -14.3%; 2007–09: S&P 500 -56.8%, gold +25.5%, silver +1.1%; 2011: S&P 500 -19.4%, gold +7.8%, silver -36.2%; 2018: S&P 500 -19.8%, gold +4.1%, silver +3.1%; 2020: S&P 500 -33.9%, gold -4.9%, silver -31.8%; 2022: S&P 500 -25.4%, gold -7.5%, silver -16.9%; 2025: S&P 500 -18.9%, gold +2.7%, silver -7.9%. Gold was higher at the trough in 7 of 10.S&P 500GoldSilver1987-34%+6%-12%1990-20%+7%-11%1998-19%-7%-10%2000–02-49%+12%-14%2007–09-57%+26%+1%2011-19%+8%-36%2018-20%+4%+3%2020-34%-5%-32%2022-25%-8%-17%2025-19%+3%-8%
Change from each S&P 500 closing high to its closing low (price only; the 2011 decline is measured from its April 2011 high). Bullion Trading LLC research; data: S&P 500 daily closes, LBMA gold and silver prices.

The counts hide rough paths. From October 2007 to March 2009 gold ended 25.5% higher but fell as much as 29.5% inside that window. In the crash of February to March 2020 gold ended 4.9% lower and silver 31.8% lower, and in 2022 gold lost 7.5% while stocks fell 25.4%. The guide to how much gold and silver to own has the full table.

Myth: physical gold rises in a recession even when paper gold falls. Fact: both track one price. Gold rose in most of the stock-market declines since 1987 but not all of them, and silver fell in most.

What can go wrong with paper metal?

  • Funds: if the trust’s gold is lost or stolen, its recovery may be limited to the custodian that held it, the SPDR Gold Trust says, and fees reduce the gold per share every year.
  • Futures: leverage cuts both ways; a margin call can force a sale at the worst moment, and contracts expire and must be rolled or settled.
  • Unallocated accounts: “the account holder is an unsecured creditor” of the dealer, so in an insolvency the metal may not be identifiable as yours. See allocated vs unallocated storage.
  • Mining shares: a mine adds costs, debt, management and country risk, so its shares can fall while the metal rises.

What can go wrong with physical metal?

You pay the premium up front and a spread when you sell, so short holdings lose money even when the price is flat. Metal must be stored and insured: a standard New York homeowners policy pays at most $200 for stolen bullion, gold and silver unless it is insured separately (NY DFS), as the guide to storing precious metals explains. Counterfeits exist, and selling means a visit to a dealer or an insured shipment rather than a click.

How are paper and physical metals taxed?

Physical bullion and shares of bullion trusts are taxed alike. Gains on a “collectible” held more than a year are taxed at up to 28% rather than the 20% top rate for most assets, and a sale of shares in a trust that holds collectibles is treated as a sale of collectibles (IRS Topic 409; SPDR Gold Trust FAQ). Regulated futures follow another rule: gains and losses count as 60% long-term and 40% short-term however long the contract was held, and open contracts are marked to market at year-end (IRS Form 6781). Mining shares are taxed like other stocks.

How the research was done

Declines: every fall of 15% or more in the S&P 500’s daily close since 1987, from closing high to closing low, with gold and silver compared on the same two days using LBMA prices (5 pm New York closes after 28 September 2026). Premiums: Bullion Trading LLC check/wire prices, recorded about four times a day since 27 October 2024, divided by the value of each product’s metal at that day’s spot close and restated over the Ask; medians by product type. Limits: one dealer’s prices, and stock declines are not recessions, though each of the last four recessions dated by the NBER (1990, 2001, 2008 and 2020) overlaps one of them.

The bottom line

Paper and physical gold and silver follow one price, so neither protects against a fall in that price, and history shows gold has not risen in every downturn. What differs is what you hold. A fund costs little to buy and sell and a small fee every year, and you rely on its trustee and custodians. Coins and bars cost a premium up front, need storage, and are the only form with no institution between you and the metal.

Frequently asked questions

What is paper silver?

A claim on silver or its price rather than the metal itself: shares of a silver fund such as SLV, silver futures, unallocated silver accounts or silver mining shares.

Is paper silver safe?

It carries different risks from metal: a fund depends on its trustee and custodians, futures on margin, and an unallocated account on the provider staying solvent. None of them removes the risk of silver’s price falling.

Can you exchange gold ETF shares for physical gold?

Not directly for most investors. The SPDR Gold Trust redeems only with Authorized Participants, in blocks of 100,000 shares; an individual would have to arrange an exchange through a broker.

Sources

Previous Post 24K Gold Casting Grain: Price per Gram, How It's Sold and How Much to Order
Next Post Buying Gold and Silver from Online Bullion Dealers